Which Mayonnaise Is Best For Pizza in 2024?

Mayonnaise with pizza isn’t something we hear every day, but many people love having mayonnaise with their favorite slice of pizza.

But most of the time avoid the situation because they think it might look weird. But others don’t know how incredible pizza tastes if you use the right flavor of mayonnaise with your pizza.

So that’s why to get rid of all the stereotypes and help people understand the benefits of using mayonnaise on pizza and the flavors they should look for in mayonnaise to use it on pizza, this article is the best way to understand all these.



Benefits of using mayonnaise on pizza

Having pizza with your family and watching a movie on the weekend is a great experience. And what makes the experience even better is when the pizza is made at home.

In homemade pizza, you can add any flavor, especially a mayonnaise of your choice. Many people will say, ‘Who adds mayonnaise on a pizza?’ but those people don’t know the benefits of using mayonnaise on a store-bought or homemade pizza.

● You add some creamy texture to the pizza by adding spicy and creamy mayonnaise.

● If your homemade pizza is slightly dry, mayonnaise can make the bread soft but not soggy.

● You can add some new flavors to your pizza because of the mayonnaise.

● Few flavors like Chipotle, olive oil, etc. These flavors are hard to incorporate into a pizza, so using a flavored mayonnaise makes it easier.

● Then if you are on a diet and trying to have a cheat meal, adding mayonnaise is a great option instead of using cheese.

● Mayonnaise is cheaper than cheese.


ReadHellmanns Mayonnaise


Factors to consider when choosing mayonnaise for pizza

Which Mayonnaise Is Best For Pizza

Those who don’t like mayonnaise on their pizza are not natural things, and there are also reasons behind that. If you add any mayonnaise at the top of your pizza, then it will ruin its taste of it, so that’s why based on the flavor of your pizza, you must choose the mayonnaise flavor as well.

So, for example, if you are having a barbecue chicken or chicken pepperoni pizza in that case, regular mayonnaise will destroy the taste of your pizza. In that case, you can add some spicy or Japanese mayonnaise to increase your pizza’s taste and umami.

Then, if you have a veg pizza or pizza containing pineapple, you can add olive or avocado oil mayonnaise to it. This kind of mayonnaise has a subtle taste that will complement the taste of your pizza and will give it a creamy texture.

Then if you like cheese on your pizza but don’t want to use it or don’t want to add more of the cheese to your pizza, you can add a little cheesy mayonnaise to it. It will give your pizza the cheesiness you want and make it tastier.

Then you can also use a small amount of real mayonnaise as a base taste of your pizza, and above that, you can add pizza sauce and the toppings you want. Through this, there will be a slight mayonnaise taste with the soft creamy texture you want on your pizza.

Etc. These are a few examples you must remember while choosing a mayonnaise for your pizza. You can’t just add any mayonnaise you want as it won’t compliment the taste of your pizza and will taste bad.


ReadTop 10 Mayonnaise Brands in the USA


Which Mayonnaise Is Best For Pizza?

Below we share some best Mayonnaise for Pizza. Choosing a proper mayonnaise for your pizza is difficult, and you want to find anyone who can guide you with that, as most people will think that you are mad or don’t know anything about pizza.

But if you use the right flavor and mayonnaise on your pizza, it will taste amazing. So, to guide you with that, here are the Best Mayonnaise you can try on your pizza.


1〉 Hellmann’s Organic Spicy Chipotle Mayonnaise

Hellmann’s Organic Spicy Chipotle Mayonnaise is at the top of the list because of its delicious taste. This mayonnaise is a combination of spicy with a little bit of sweetness.

This combination gives the pizza a smoky flavor. And not only that, the texture of this mayonnaise is creamy, rich, and easily spreadable, so you can easily use a little bit of Hellmann’s Organic Spicy Chipotle Mayonnaise on top of your chicken pizza.

Apart from that, this mayo is made with organic ingredients, and cage-free eggs also have no added preservatives, making the mayonnaise quality even better.

Price: $6 for 15 oz.


2〉 Kewpie Japanese style mayonnaise

Kewpie mayonnaise is one of the top mayonnaise brands in the United States. And this Japanese-style mayonnaise is the Mayonnaise recipe that made everyone crazy about it.

It has a luxurious taste of Asian flavor, some sweetness, and is slightly citrusy. And the extra flavor of MSG gives this mayonnaise an umami that no other mayonnaise has. 

That’s why if you are having a veg pizza or mostly any pizza of your choice, you can add the Kewpie Japanese style mayonnaise.

It will complement the taste of your non-veg or veg pizza and will add rich, creamy, and umami. And even if your pizza has pineapple, you can also use this mayo as the salty, sour taste of the mayo will balance the favors. 

Price: $7.12 for 17.64 fl oz.


3〉 Duke’s Bacon and Tomato-Flavoured Mayo 

The Duke’s Bacon and Tomato Flavoured Mayo is a great option to add some heat to your margarita pizza. This mayonnaise is made using the original recipe of Duke’s real mayonnaise.

Because of this, while using the bacon and tomato-flavored mayonnaise, you can taste the kick of roasted bacon and the slightly tangy taste that you can feel at the back of your tongue. 

This mayonnaise is a must-have in your kitchen; you can use it for everyday purposes. Still, if you are making homemade pizza, a thin layer of the Duke’s Bacon and Tomato Flavoured Mayonnaise will make your bacon, cheese, or margarita pizza taste better.

Price: $4.99 for 14 fl oz


4〉 Spectrum Culinary Organic Mayonnaise with Olive Oil

Suppose you are having or making a California-style pizza with seafood or black olives etc.

As a topping, in that case, using the Spectrum Culinary with Extra Virgin Olive Oil Organic Mayonnaise will increase the taste of your pizza even more.

It has a rich and creamy taste that complements the taste of your pizza, and it goes perfectly if you have shrimp on your pizza. 

This mayonnaise is made with organic ingredients, cage-free eggs, and enriched with the taste of extra virgin olive oil. And the texture of this makes it easier to spread over your pizza. So by having this mayonnaise at home, you can use it in many other flavors of pizza you like. 

Price: $9 for 12 fl oz.


5〉 Duke’s Habanero Garlic Mayonnaise

This mayonnaise is a sealed deal for all the non-veg pizzas in the US. If you like spicy food, then the combination of hot Habanero and Garlic in mayonnaise is the perfect combination you need.

It will enhance the taste of your pizza, give it a smooth texture, and, most importantly, make your Pizza taste even better. So to spice up your life, this no added sugar mayonnaise is a perfect option for you to use on your homemade pizza. 

Price: $4.99 for 14 fl oz


6〉 Kraft Avocado Oil Mayonnaise

If you like the rich, creamy taste of avocado oil mayonnaise, you will love the taste of Kraft Avocado oil Mayonnaise on your margarita pizza.

Kraft avocado oil mayonnaise is rich and creamy, and when you spread it on top of your pizza, it helps to get rid of the dryness of the pizza and gives a smooth texture. This way, you can easily add this mayonnaise to any dry or tasteless pizza to make it taste better. 

Price: $4.38 for 30fl oz


7〉 Chosen Food Vegan Avocado oil Mayonnaise 

If you can’t resist your desire to have a pizza, then making it at home will be much healthier instead of buying store brought pizza.

And on your homemade pizza, you should add Chosen Food Vegan Avocado oil Mayonnaise instead of adding lots of cheese.

This great taste of mayonnaise gives your homemade pizza a Creamy texture that store-bought pizzas have. And you can incorporate vegan mayonnaise with corn, vegan tofu, and vegetables. 

Price: $19.99 for 12 fl oz



So, in the end, as you can understand that they are good sides to using mayonnaise in pizza. There is so much deliciously flavored mayonnaise available in the market; once you start understanding which mayonnaise goes with which kind of pizzas, you can incorporate those flavors on a different level.

So, enjoy your pizza, and if someone judges you for using mayonnaise on your pizza, just ignore it; if you love it, just do it. 



Below we share some FAQs

Is it weird to dip pizza in mayonnaise?

If you think you will dip your pizza’s life in mayonnaise before eating it, then, unfortunately, it is weird. Dipping the pizza mayonnaise will take away most of the Pizza taste, so instead of dipping it again, you must spread a little bit of mayonnaise at the top of your pizza.

With this method, there will be a taste balance between the taste of Pizza and Mayonnaise. 


How many calories does pizza with mayonnaise have?

Different flavors of pizzas contain different amounts of calories. Still, on average, a slice of pizza contains 200 calories, and if you add one tablespoon of mayonnaise to your slice of pizza, then it will add almost 90-100 calories. So, a single slice of store-bought pizza with added mayonnaise will have around 300 calories.


Does pizza with mayonnaise taste good?

Most people don’t like mayonnaise on their pizza, but there is a reason behind it. Pizza does test well with mayonnaise, but you must understand which will perfectly incorporate your pizza flavor.

If you have a smokey spicy chicken pizza and add a tangy tested mayonnaise, it will win the taste, so, just because people don’t understand much about flavored mayonnaise, that’s why they avoid it.


Is it safe to eat pizza with mayonnaise if left overnight?

There isn’t any problem with eating your pizza the next day if it is kept in the refrigerator. But eating fresh pizza is better than keeping it overnight, but if you can’t finish your pizza, try to finish it the next day during lunch.

Keeping the pizza with mayonnaise for more than 12-14 hours will make it taste bitter and soggy.